Apologists for the NSA’s domestic data collection activities love to defend the practice with the excuse “It’s just metadata, it’s not content,” but a new study proves this is totally false. Metadata gives the agency the ability to make precise inferences about the most personal aspects of our private lives, including “familial, political, professional, religious, and sexual associations.”
William Binney, a highly-regarded data analyst, mathematician and NSA whistle-blower warned of the same thing as early as June of 2013. “When you take all those records of who’s communicating with who, you can build social networks and communities for everyone in the world … And when you marry it up with the content you have leverage against everybody in the country,” he said. Binney beileved that NSA was collecting content as well, despite what higher-ups have stated about the data miners. Mark Rumold, a staff attorney at the Electronic Frontier Foundation, told the Daily Intelligencer that the NSA uses “metadata to create communications maps of Americans. So when they have a target — someone they believe is connected to terrorism — pull up their communications map.” In their study, computer scientists Jonathan Mayer and Patrick Mutchler were able to create a smaller-scale mapping by getting a handle on the app-users’ contacts and labeling the ones related to “sensitive activity” by an organization’s obvious line of business or a quick Google search. The result: legitimate inferences about real people based on their individual calls to sensitive numbers and habitual calling patterns. For example: The case of religious organizations gave us an opportunity to check the precision of our inferences. Since the MetaPhone app collects a user’s religion from his or her Facebook profile, we could compare phone metadata inferences against ground truth. There were 15 participants with both a well-defined religious status on Facebook (including atheism) and phone contact with a religious organization. Using just the naïve assumption that a person’s most-called religion is their own religion, we accurately identified the religious status of 11 of the 15 (73%). Many numbers were associated with specialized products or services, particularly within professional fields. In medicine, for example, we were able to easily categorize phone numbers by specialty practice area. The degree of sensitivity among contacts took us aback. Participants had calls with Alcoholics Anonymous, gun stores, NARAL Pro-Choice, labor unions, divorce lawyers, sexually transmitted disease clinics, a Canadian import pharmacy, strip clubs, and much more. This was not a hypothetical parade of horribles. These were simple inferences, about real phone users, that could trivially be made on a large scale. This means the NSA data collection must not be dismissed as “just” metadata, first because even metadata gives the agency and the government that controls it unparalleled power over citizens, and second because of the likelihood that the surveillance apparatus collects far more than metadata. If you question the importance of this degree of citizen-spying, just start to imagine what the government could do with the ability to target specific groups and individuals for harassment. For example, groups who speak out against government policies… The study unequivocally concludes that, although there is room to debate the mining policy and potential legal constraints, phone metadata is “highly sensitive” and not something to discount cavalierly.The study crowdsourced its own metadata through the MetaPhone app, which submitted Android device logs and social network information for analysis. Despite an exceedingly small MetaPhone population, the analysts discovered that phone metadata was “unambiguously sensitive” and useful for inferring medical details, gun ownership and more.
Source: Rare
what ever happened to the right to privacy? Anyone?
Down the tubes
.
.
….~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
………••*´¨`*•. N O R A .•*´¨`*••
……Social Networking as it should be
….~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
● N O R A – Gives you Your Privacy back!
● N O R A – is NEW
● N O R A – is user friendly
● N O R A – is secure
● N O R A – will never sell YOUR content
● N O R A – will never spam you
● N O R A – will never punish you for sending a friend request
● N O R A – will never limit the number of friends you can have
● N O R A – will reward you
● N O R A – values YOU and YOUR content, ALWAYS!
● N O R A – is the way Social Networking should be!
● N O R A – is inviting YOU to visit them
● N O R A – has all the usual social networking features, games, IM
● N O R A – has live radio from around the World
● N O R A – has links to some of the latest movies, streamed for your viewing pleasure
● N O R A – has links to your latest videos, music, news, current affairs, info, comedy
● N O R A – gives you the tools to personalize your profile page layout
● N O R A – let’s you write blogs, set up groups, create pages
● N O R A – goes where you go, special app. for your mobile devices
● N O R A – doesn’t retain your content once you delete it, its gone!
● N O R A – has so much more……..come for a visit
Now there IS, somewhere else to go……http://tinyurl.com/nora-is-this-way
● N O R A – IS Secure. Don’t believe me?
Search for me, Adam Marks, on the Nora website. You won’t find me. NORA is blocking all the search engines “spiders” and “crawlers”. You will have your privacy back.
Search also for Erwin Noever and Jose Raba……the owners of NORA.
……………………………………………………
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
NOTE to PROFILE OWNER –
– this is not SPAM. You opened dialogue with me, when we had previously had none. If you no longer wish to receive my communication, please feel free to remove my profile from your contact list. Thank you kindly. Have an awesome day. Cheers ~ ADAM
there is no privacy any more the nsa should be shut down
Don’t use your phone on the crapper, they’re watching you p**p, for your own good.
I really love your site.. Excellent colors & theme. Did you develop this web site yourself?
Please reply back as I’m wanting to create my own website and would love to find out where you
got this from or exactly what the theme is named. Cheers!
Hello, i feel that i saw you visited my weblog thus i came to go back the want?.I am attempting to in finding things to enhance
my web site!I suppose its good enough to use a few of your ideas!!
Ce ρost est plein dde magnifiգues conseils